Download App
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • X
HomeCompareKia Carnival vs Proton Saga

Kia Carnival vs Proton Saga: Price, Specs & Which to Buy

Last updated: 22 Nov 2026 · Malaysia Market

Kia Carnival
Kia Carnival
RM 189,849
Proton Saga
Proton Saga
RM 38,990

Verdict: Which Car Should You Buy?

Both run on petrol, so fuel bills and running costs stay in the same ballpark. The Saga is the cheaper way in at RM 38,990, undercutting the Carnival by RM 150,859. With no clear hardware advantage to justify the difference, the Carnival is harder to recommend.

Key Differences

  • Price: Carnival RM 189,849; Saga RM 38,990
  • Length: Carnival 5155 mm; Saga 4390 mm

Pros & Cons

Kia Carnival 2.2T Standard 11 Seats (2025)

Pros

  • Competitive on price for what it offers

Cons

  • Higher entry price

Proton Saga 1.5L AT Standard (2025)

Pros

  • Lower price at RM 38,990

Find the Right Car

Choose the Carnival if you want...

  • a 360-degree camera as standard
  • 56 L of boot space
  • a 2.2-litre engine

Choose the Saga if you want...

  • the lowest purchase price (RM 38,990)
  • a compact body that's easy to park and thread through traffic
  • a 1.5-litre engine

Which car suits your lifestyle best?

  • Family buyers: Carnival — 11 seats suits family duty better
  • Daily commuters: Saga — the lower price and compact dimensions that are easy to park make it a cheap city runabout
  • Budget-conscious buyers: Saga — saves RM 150,859 upfront

Price & Ownership Costs

ParameterKia CarnivalProton Saga
Price RM 189,848.8RM 38,990 ✓
Body Type / Seats 5 door MPV · 11 seats4 door Sedan · 5 seats
Assembly CKDLocal Manufactured
Annual Road Tax RM 560.80RM 90 ✓

Engine, Fuel Economy & Refuelling

ParameterKia CarnivalProton Saga
Engine Capacity 2,151 cc ✓1,499 cc
Rated Economy -5.1 L/100km
Fuel Tank 72 L ✓40 L

Both run conventional petrol engines. The Saga uses a 1.5-litre naturally-aspirated engine; the Carnival a 2.2-litre turbocharged engine.

Power & Performance

ParameterKia CarnivalProton Saga
Max Power 202 Ps ✓120 Ps
Max Torque 440 N·m ✓150 N·m
Drivetrain FWDFWD
Transmission ATAT

Dimensions

ParameterKia CarnivalProton Saga
Length 5,155 mm ✓4,390 mm
Width 1,995 mm ✓1,690 mm
Height 1,775 mm ✓1,525 mm
Wheelbase 3,090 mm ✓2,465 mm
Boot Capacity 56-2689 L-

The Carnival is the longer car — 765 mm up at 5155 mm versus 4390 mm. The Carnival also leads on wheelbase, 3090 mm versus 2465 mm. The Carnival seats 11.

Comfort & Technology

Carnival

  • 12.3" central touchscreen + 12.3" digital cluster
  • Dual-zone automatic climate control
  • Wireless phone charging
  • Power tailgate
  • Heated and power-folding door mirrors

Saga

  • 9" touchscreen

Key Specs Compared

ParameterKia CarnivalProton Saga
Overview
Price RM 189,848.8RM 38,990 ✓
Body Type 5 door MPV4 door Sedan
Seats 11 seats ✓5 seats
Assembly CKDLocal Manufactured
Performance
Max Power 202 Ps ✓120 Ps
Max Power 148.4 kW ✓88 kW
Max Torque 440 N·m ✓150 N·m
Drivetrain FWDFWD
Transmission ATAT
Dimensions
Length 5,155 mm ✓4,390 mm
Width 1,995 mm ✓1,690 mm
Height 1,775 mm ✓1,525 mm
Wheelbase 3,090 mm ✓2,465 mm
Kerb Weight 2,129 kg1,055 kg
Boot Capacity 56-2689 L-

Image Gallery

FAQs

Is the Saga or Carnival better?

The Saga is the cheaper of the two at RM 38,990, but the Carnival answers back with more equipment for the money.

What is the price difference between the Saga and Carnival?

The Saga starts at RM 38,990, the Carnival at RM 189,849 — about RM 150,859 in favour of the Saga.

Which is bigger?

The Carnival is longer, at 5155 mm against 4390 mm.

Do both cars come with advanced driver assistance?

The Carnival lists autonomous emergency braking, adaptive cruise control and blind-spot monitoring; the other car's equipment list does not confirm these items.

Feedback